The Questions Executives Regret Not Asking Before Accepting a Leadership Role

One of the patterns I've observed repeatedly over more than three decades in executive search is that executives don't regret asking too many thoughtful questions.

They regret the questions they never asked.

Why Great Opportunities Create Blind Spots

Excitement narrows focus. When a credible and truly attractive career opportunity presents itself, candidates should absolutely be enthusiastic. Hiring companies want to see engagement, and an outstanding opportunity may offer a step up in title, compensation and equity participation; exceptional people; cutting-edge science; or the chance to move from a slow-moving bureaucracy into a faster, more entrepreneurial culture.

Those are all legitimate reasons for enthusiasm. They can also distract candidates from disciplined due diligence. Paradoxically, the more attractive the opportunity appears, the more rigorous the evaluation should become.

The Questions Outstanding Executives Ask

Beyond the fundamentals, the single most important question I encourage candidates to ask is: "Why is this position open?" It is also one of the first subjects I cover with a client in a search kickoff meeting. In my experience, the answer almost always leads to additional — and often more revealing — questions.

  • It's a newly created position because of company growth. That is generally positive, but candidates should understand the growth story, business model and resources supporting the role. Just as important, they should confirm that the stakeholders share the same vision for the position. I've seen instances in which interviews with multiple stakeholders uncovered meaningful differences in expectations that required additional mutual due diligence before everyone was truly aligned.

  • The previous incumbent departed the company. How long was that person in the role? How long had the predecessor served? Were they successful? What were the metrics? Are there internal candidates for the position? If not, does the organization have talent-development or succession-planning issues that the incoming executive will need to address?

  • The incumbent is currently in the role. I've led many confidential searches in which an organization decided that a leadership change was necessary before the incumbent departed. Different interviewing protocols may be appropriate, but candidates still need a candid understanding of why the change is being made and what the organization expects to be different going forward.

Beyond the scope of the role, I encourage candidates to ask about the vision for it. Budgets, KPIs and metrics matter, but so does the impact the organization expects the executive to have beyond functional responsibilities. What kind of leader flourishes there? What behaviors are rewarded? Conversely, what kinds of leaders have struggled, and why?

As interviews progress into the middle and later stages, candidates should pay close attention to disconnects among stakeholders. Some are obvious — different views about budgets, priorities or 90-, 180- and 365-day expectations. Others are subtler and more consequential.

One of my most memorable CEO placements went especially deep in his Board interviews, asking candid questions about how difficult decisions were actually made, internal politics, and other issues that directly affected the role. He surfaced important realities before accepting the position and entered with his eyes wide open. More than a decade later, he remains in that CEO role.

Another question that almost always stimulates a rich conversation is asking an interviewer why they personally joined the organization. As candidates meet multiple stakeholders, at least one has often joined relatively recently. When leaders stop giving rehearsed corporate answers and tell their own story, the conversation can reveal far more about culture, leadership and future direction than another discussion of the organizational chart.

Questions Candidates Rarely Think to Ask

Years ago, a very savvy Head of CMC candidate asked a hiring leader and other stakeholders, "What surprised you most after joining?" It was a terrific question, and I've encouraged candidates to ask it ever since.

Another penetrating question is, "What will be the most difficult challenge about succeeding here?" And one I hear far too rarely is, "When leaders have struggled here, have you noticed any common themes?" The converse can be equally revealing: "What characteristics do your most successful leaders share?"

These are search-side questions that differentiate thoughtful executives. I've rarely seen candidates receive pushback for asking them professionally. More often, the answers provide valuable information that becomes part of the candidate's eventual decision.

Every great question serves two purposes. It gives the candidate better information, and it tells the hiring organization something important about the candidate. Thoughtful questions demonstrate judgment, curiosity and executive maturity.

Search-Side Observation

One thing I have seen consistently over the decades is that smart, insightful questions that go well beyond the job description are respected and appreciated by hiring leaders and companies. There is nothing unprofessional or off-putting about asking challenging questions when they are asked with professionalism and high EQ.

Thoughtful candidates almost never damage their candidacy by asking insightful questions professionally.

Much more often...

they distinguish themselves.

Every executive interview is a two-way evaluation. One organization is deciding whether you're the right leader. You're deciding whether they're the right organization. The quality of that decision often depends on the quality of the questions neither side thought to ask.

Candidates and hiring leaders often regret the questions they never asked. Great opportunities welcome great due diligence.

The quality of a career decision is often determined by the quality of the questions asked before the offer is accepted.

Previous
Previous

Why Outstanding Executives Sometimes Make Career Decisions They Later Regret